Look at the finish from the approach and up close
Hold two painted samples vertically beside the exterior trim. Look straight at them and then from an angle where light travels across the surface. A smooth sample shows reflections clearly, while a textured sample can change how flat the same sheen looks. Think about how you use the door. If bags or bicycles regularly brush past the handle, ask for the maker's directions for dealing with scratches or chips on each surface.
Compare the pieces below and around the skin
Ask each seller to identify the core, edges and frame. Look at how the leaf meets the seal at the bottom and both sides. If a performance figure matters, confirm that it belongs to the complete configuration with the frame and glass you are considering. A value from a solid door can be a poor comparison for a glazed version. Keep the coating name and any exposure limits with the drawing.
Make the decision from two comparable samples
Record one reason you would choose each option. Use the same colour and similar glass layout if possible. That makes it easier to see whether a difference comes from the material or the finish.